CAP_H'S PROFILE

author=demonlord5000
Small observation. I went back to read caps reads and his original fakedoctor pick was emily as well, but also immediately disagreed with psy's analysis of emily. Cap, why did you originally pick emily over oldpat as your pick for being scum?

I think you can find it in my posts. I originally found old to be sketchier, but I reread the thread and Alaskan's cc was very risky.

author=demonlord5000
I think the only chance of that happening is through nolynch and getting more information. If fomar is scum he is practically forced to kill one of us or oddrabbit, but then there is a chance of odd revealing the miller which could be very good for us.

I think this post should be used as an evidence against you. Earlier, you happily jumped on psy and now you talk about no lynch as our only chance. Sounds like a contradiction. Compare it with Emily's post. She's way more consistent

Fomar, what do you think about both me and psy calling demon wolf? To me it's a weird situation.

Psy, I don't find your case for w!Emily quite convincing. There are few assumptions I see as debatable at best. Like her lurking to counter claim. It's true that both claims happened surprisingly fast, but why would scum plan to do that? I can see myself doing something like that in a desperate situation but not on d1.

I believe that Fomar is town. In his long walls, which would be unnecessary if he were wolf and you town, there isn't a single point, which would show a hole in perspective.
The only thing I'm afraid of is that with all three of us scumreading Demonlord, something might be off. Like tale being scum, because tale feels quite scummy outside of his claim.
If I discredit that as a bastard mechanic it always leaves me with you and demon as wolves at this point. I can't help it.

author=psy_wombats
Oh, also -- with every role read and person dead, my claim as miller improves. If cap or fomar die as villager, then even with no prior knowledge, then Tale's scumread on me becomes more likely to /exonerate/ me -- scum would be lawyered up, and it'd be 50/50 from the remaining roles alone that I'm the miller.

true, but we're not getting there without wolves dying and we can't really get over 50% because of Jero.

Tbh, fomar arriving at many of the same conclusions as I (in a less chaotic fashion) makes me townread him and more convinced that it's indeed demon/psy/old (with an outside chance of emily being the last one instead of Old).

Is there a scenario you prefer?

author=demonlord5000
I'm pretty convinced fomar is town cap. I just got up myself and read. My theory is that scum knew the next day would be mylo, townread me after my defense post, and then found a reason to go after LP. I would not have gone after LP so hard with a not great argument as scum. That's all I had though. I think it could be a good idea to look back at the end of d1 and look at how quickly LP got lynched.

If you were town, it wouldn't be difficult for scum to townread you. I considered all options and you always make sense as wolf.

author=tale
@Cap does no-lynch in Day 2 ends up LYLO? I'll be busy for 2 hours.

@Fomar I'm trying understand future days if psy isn't a miller- Plan 1
odd probably going to get nk because of being a confirmed town?
At the same time depending on odd's target will reveal a role.
If it's vanilla, then it's hard to determine unless it's one of doctors.

We're in mylo. We can't mislynch. So, going for no kill should give you another peek (Emily's more likely town because she mentioned doctor being able to protect you consecutively). With two peeks and one less unknown, we might be in a better situation to sort out psy. And yes, it would result in a ly-lo.