MUFFLE'S PROFILE

author=Jeroen_Sol
If two people got attacked, it heavily implies one got attacked by town. That means being attacked is no indication of anyone's alignment.

Yea, that's also true. But unless this game is different than the one I played, there should only be one person that can shoot another person off on each team. If this is correct - and I have no way of knowing if this is true - then one of these people could be lying to try and dodge any suspicion since Gourd was lynched and so, therefore, couldn't shoot off anyone.

author=Jeroen_Sol
Of this list, demon and Yellow are most scummy to me. demon's reason for joining the bandwagon wasn't convincing to me. I agree with having a lynch over a nolynch, but that "not having a valid argument before my next post" business doesn't sit right with me. A valid argument for or against what? That doesn't answer my question of what was his original reason for suspecting Gourd, even if he wasn't fully convinced. YM's "But, like, what do you want me to say that wouldn't be seen as me Mafia bandwagoning?" line feels like lampshading to me. One of the best ways to deal with people thinking something is scummy is to accept it looks scummy and then try to move on.

This is also true, and I agree here.

author=Jeroen_Sol
I'm also still wary of Ozzy. It's not rare for scum to vehemently defend a doomed townie to get towncred on flip.

This is also true. However, if I am correct as to nobody knows who is who wouldn't it just be a coincidence that this happened? Like I said, I'm not sure about this game though and how it works, so I could be totally wrong.

author=pianotm
LockeZ is a hard town read for me.
Yellow Magic is Yellow Magic, and he's absent enough that he's going to be a difficult read.
Muffle, I'm not sure about. She read as new town to me, but now that Gourd has flipped town, I'm looking at the way she and LockeZ bickered.
Jeroen_Sol, he tried to be helpful, but he might be helpful scum.
demonlord5000's lack of posting and how little he's actually contributed is concerning.

Um, how is bickering exactly suspicious anyway? If I am correct, none of us know who is Town and who is Mafia, and we aren't allowed to talk in PM anyways. So it's not like I and LockeZ were like "Oh we're Mafia let's team up to look all towny". I think that sounds a bit far-fetched considering this point. However, I do understand why it does seem a bit strange mostly since we both voted for Gourd right after that. But as I said before, I was going to vote to lynch Gourd before the bickering. The reason we bickered was that I was arguing my case, as court and law. Also, I'm not even smart enough to form a plan like that even if I wanted too XD The reason why I regret it is because the gunner is usually very handy in these cases. But at least it does point us in a direction, I guess.

As of right now, I'm honestly stumped :\ I have my eye on LockeZ because I know how smart he is, that's not my full reasoning of course because that's idiotic. Cave is making a lot of chaotic good (or maybe neutral?) so I honestly can't tell, I'm reading kind of innocent but you can never be sure. Especially since I totally read Gourd completely wrong. Everything else is as pianotm said, though some of Esby and Ozzy's comments do come off a little bit strange - though this could be because they're kind of one-liners.

I deeply regret lynching Gourd.

Ozzy, don't yell at us. How did you know? I mean, what made you suspect Gourd was a villager? Was it just a gut feeling? I'm just curious since it just seemed there was so much suspicion coming from them.

author=ESBY
i refuse to kill the gourd
i will however, for being too eager to point blame at anyone

#lynch pianotm

Can you give reasoning? Just saying "I refuse to kill Gourd" doesn't really make sense, unless you're meaning to be vague.

author=Gourd_Clae
r-relax O.o

H-Huh? I'm not mad? I thought I was being calm in my post. Sorry if I came off aggressive?