MUFFLE'S PROFILE

I'm looking at the balance of the game at this point. It'd be overpowered for scum to have revival. Scum is a team that knows who each other is, if one is on the fence of being lynched, pop the ability and move on. In order to allow such a powerful ability as to save someone from lynch, I think it'd be better used as a town ability since we have no idea who's who. So the possibility of reviving scum could be a risk. That's my reason as to why I think it's specifically a town power. The power would never be popped by scum if the lynch was town causing for meta gameplay.

author=psy_wombats
yeah, for throwing around uncertainty re:AE and being sure that 1) Fomar is town, and 2) Fomar's day ability revived AE. I'm 80% sure of #2 but it's not like Lavos having a ~final form~ is exactly something unheard of for an innate power. #1 I don't really like because Fomar wanted Cap or himself, not AE, and it took like three people voting against her and prodding him for him to actually flip his vote. Plus the whole he-probably-revived-her thing. And he has a roleblock power, which went unused because Emily managed to set herself on fire. He's not clear in my book, not really someone I'd want dead, but not clear.

*knowing* both of those things is something I'd expect of scum only

I only am sure that Fomar's day ability was revival because when he was close to being lynched he even tried to lynch himself off after a day ability had been claimed to be used. He kept pushing for a lynch saying that if a lynch didn't happen his power would be useless, than when the lynch happened AE was revived. It makes total sense why Fomar went about it that way, and again, my reason for thinking Fomar is town is I can't see a scum ability being revival. But I guess I see why you lynched me now, thanks for clearing that up.

@demonlord because I know I look super scummy from the whole odd train, not lynching cuz I was absent, yada yada. Several people said they would be okay with lynching me yesterday but AE was picked over me, which means its likely I could be next. Also it's been a while since I've played RMN mafia, the mafia I played last lynches happened in like 10 mins so I guess I felt unneeded pressure from previous games LOLL. I just know I can help town so I felt like I had to claim I guess cuz again I feel like I'm the next best lynch.

author=demonlord5000
Alright, so emily revived and needs to die. I won't put down a lynch yet because she's on fire, but it's worth considering lynching her anyways because we don't know if scum can heal or not. Assuming crono blocked her last night (that was a night power right?, I need to reread), that means we have a town aligned fire user too.

The way emily revived concerns me, because it happened at the end of the day phase. This makes me think a day power revived her. There were two day powers used in day 1, cronos, which we still have no clue what it was supposed to do, and an unknown power that we don't know who used it at all.

I think we need to hear from fomar before making any decisions though.

Fire using town is also a good thing to think about, too focused on the fact Lavos is on fire that I didn't even think there might be a fire user in town. It makes more sense to me than revival+alignment shift power. But again I'm not sure. If AE dies today and it turns out AE is actually town that was alignment shifted, will we lose more than if we bet AE is town and save them and they turn out to be scum? We'd definitely get more information if they die either way, though that sounds awfully bad put it that way. We're only on Day 2 afterall, still not a whole lot to go on, but I want to see every little corner I can. I'd also like to see Fomar's reply to all this.

Okay first of all I'd like to apologize for not being there for end game vote. I had to go to an appointment the moment I woke up and by the time I had gotten back everything had been said and done. Anyways, first I'd like to say, wow I'm probably gonna get lynched next. Odd's death is gonna look bad on the odd train and I also didn't vote for AE who happened to be scum, also good job on Fomar for that, considering you can revive I see how you weren't worried in the first place. But I swear! If I was here I would've voted for AE and I believed that odd was town when he claimed frog!

Okay, first things first. Fomar is definitely town, he was able to find a scum on first day since he was the one who managed to get AE lynched. There's no reason for scum to throw another scum under the train on the first day unless they're confident and want to look super town aligned the rest of the game? But I don't see a revival ability being scum aligned.

AE is still in game because of revival but looks like they'll die anyways, unless scum has a healing ability? I'd say we should try and focus on lynching another scum off unless maybe we should worry about a scum healer saving AE? I mean we're not gonna believe AE anymore anyways but we also should worry about their abilities right?.. Ehhh.

Now that AE is down I'm gonna go back and see if I can read anything on anyone else. Was there anyone that seemed to be in links with AE? Agreeing with AE or something something? I'll also see what other people say about all this, also rest in peace oddrabbit. I'm sorry I was thinking of lynching you, you were actually quite helpful this game, I think.